• Home   /  
  • Archive by category "1"

Jacques Cartier Problems Or Obstacles To Critical Thinking

Sir George-Étienne Cartier, co-premier of the Province of Canada, lawyer, rebel, railway promoter, politician (born 6 September 1814 in Saint-Antoine, Lower Canada; died 20 May 1873 in London, England).

Sir George-Étienne Cartier, co-premier of the Province of Canada, lawyer, rebel, railway promoter, politician, Father of Confederation (born 6 September 1814 in Saint-Antoine, Lower Canada; died 20 May 1873 in London, England). A former rebel against the government (see Rebellions of 1837), Cartier also served as Canada's first minister of militia and defence. Arguably the kingpin of Confederation, Cartier was responsible for bringing French Canada, Manitoba and British Columbia into the Dominion.

Education and Early Career

From a wealthy family of grain exporters and millers, and, according to family legend, a descendant of the family of Jacques Cartier, he dominated the politics of Québec for a generation. A graduate of the Sulpician Collège de Montréal and called to the bar in 1835, Cartier joined the radical Fils de la Liberté (Sons of Liberty), to fight against the Château Clique. He composed the patriotic song "O Canada, mon pays, mes amours" — perhaps the model for the later national anthem — and was secretary of the reorganized Saint-Jean-Baptiste Society in 1843.

The Rebellions of 1837

In 1837 at Saint-Denis, Cartier fought bravely alongside Wolfred Nelson and the rebels as they successfully routed Colonel Charles Gore's force of British regulars (seeRebellions of 1837). After a narrow escape and exile in Vermont, he successfully petitioned in 1838 to return and practise law in Montréal. Among his clients were the Sulpician Order, the original seigneurs of Montréal, and the St. Lawrence and Atlantic Railway.

Political Career

Cartier soon became active in politics and in 1841, became Louis-Hippolyte LaFontaine's campaign manager and right-hand man. The two were dedicated to reforming the Civil Code and restoring the Assembly of the Province of Lower Canada, where French Canadians held a majority and which had been nullified by the Act of Union (1840). With responsible government won in 1848, he ran and was elected as a Liberal Reformer in Verchères, and was soon brought into Cabinet.

Cartier moved to Montréal East in 1861 after the coalition with the Canada West (Upper Canadian) Conservatives, and as Bleu chief served as co-premier with John A. Macdonald in the Union parliaments of 1857–58 and 1858–62, in which ministry he set in motion the movement toward Confederation.

One of his chief achievements in the period was his engineering of the Queen’s choice in 1857 of Ottawa as the capital of the Canadas. His reasoning was this: Ottawa was more defensible militarily than Toronto, Kingston, Montréal or Québec. It was on the border between the two provinces of the Union, was also on the route of the planned railway to the northwest and the Pacific that would make Montréal the entrepôt of a continental trading system.

Confederation

In the years leading up to Confederation, Cartier and his large block of supporters from Canada East (Lower Canada) allied with Macdonald’s smaller cohort of Conservatives from Canada West (Upper Canada)to create political deadlock in the Province of Canada. They finally convinced George Brown and his supporters to join the Great Coalition, and work toward a wider union of the provinces of British North America.

In the conferences that followed, Cartier’s goal was to ensure that Canada was to be a federation of provinces rather than a single legislative union like Britain.

At the Charlottetown Conference in 1864, Cartier led the Canadian case for a great confederation of all the colonial provinces, inspiring the Maritime delegates with a commitment to build the Intercolonial Railway. At the Québec Conference, Cartier argued for the creation of a new “political nationality,” and denounced Rouge leader A.A. Dorion’s contention that French Canada would be better off joining the United States, by stating that French interests could be preserved under the proposed Confederation.

At Confederation, Cartier chose the militia portfolio, with the aim of building up a national force strong enough to resist any invasion or interference from the United States; a strong military was also key to securing the entry of the north-west into Confederation.

The West

In these first years of Confederation, Cartier often served as acting Prime Minister during Macdonald's illnesses and played a key role in securing Rupert’s Land (1869) and in drafting the Manitoba Act (1870) and British Columbia Act (1871).

In 1868–69, he and William McDougall negotiated in London for the transfer of the HBC territory of Rupert's Land and the North-Western Territory to the Dominion. Due to his close relations with British railway builders, military officials and financiers, Cartier was fully in tune with imperial interests regarding an eventual “All-Red Route” to the Pacific and Asia through Canada’s huge new territory. McDougall was appointed lieutenant-governor of the area, but was prevented from entering by Louis Riel and his men (seeRed River Resistance).

Manitoba

Cartier may have met Louis Riel (both had been educated at the Collège de Montréal, although not at the same time). Cartier sympathized with the Métis, and played a key role in negotiating their acceptance of provincehood through their emissary, Abbé Ritchot. After passage of the Manitoba Act on 12 May 1870, Cartier sent Adams Archibald and many of his own hand-picked men to administer the new province.

British Columbia

Cartier welcomed British Columbia delegates John Sebastian Helmcken, Joseph Trutch and Robert Carrall to Ottawa in June 1870, and promised them a transcontinental railway if British Columbia joined Confederation (the delegates had planned only to ask for a wagon road east). He negotiated the Terms of Union with British Columbia, which were passed in 1871.

The Transcontinental Railway

Cartier promoted the development of rail throughout his career. He was heavily involved in the development of the Grand Trunk Railway, becoming its solicitor, and chairman of the Railway Committee of Parliament in the Union government.

Cartier was also a driving force in the early promotion of the Canadian Pacific Railway, to seal the bargain with British Columbia, and make Montréal the terminus of a transcontinental trading network.

However, Cartier’s plans were opposed by rival railway promoters in Boston and Philadelphia, who wanted to tap into the trade of the Canadian north-west by railway lines crossing the border. These promoters heavily financed Cartier’s political rival in Montréal East, Louis-Amable Jetté of the short-lived Parti national, leading to Cartier’s defeat in 1872. Louis Riel quickly offered to resign his own seat in Manitoba, and Cartier soon became the MP for Saint Boniface. The American promoters then engineered the release in April 1873 of election fundraising telegrams — the so-called Pacific Scandal — while heavily subsidizing their own Canadian supporters.

Cartier, whose letters had promised to consider awarding Sir Hugh Allan the railway contract, was already mortally ill with Bright's disease when the scandal erupted in the Commons. He died soon after seeking treatment in London and the CPR languished for almost a decade.

Legacy

As the chief voice of the French Canadian community, the pivotal point of the union, Cartier was the kingpin of the Confederation movement. He masterfully made use of his block votes, and his railway and militia interests, to engineer a new union and a new nationality. He reconciled the majority of French Canada to Confederation on the grounds that it prevented annexation by the United States and made possible the end of the Union government and the restoration of the old Province of Québec. Cartier played the primary role in bringing Manitoba and British Columbia into Confederation, and negotiated the purchase of Rupert’s Land and the North-Western Territory from the Hudson’s Bay Company.

Suggested Reading

  • J. Boyd, Sir George Étienne Cartier (1914); Alastair Sweeny, George-Étienne Cartier (1976) (online revision at http://www.canadachannel.ca/cartier/); B. Young, George-Etienne Cartier (1981).

Links to other sites

  • Sir George-Étienne CartierWatch the Heritage Minute about Sir George-Étienne Cartier’s critical role in crafting Canadian Confederation. From Historica Canada.

  • Sir George-Étienne Cartier A biography of Sir George-Étienne Cartier, lawyer, politician, prime minister of the Province of Canada. From the Dictionary of Canadian Biography Online.

  • The Hon. Sir George-Étienne Cartier, P.C., Q.C.Parliamentarian File for The Hon. Sir George-Étienne Cartier, P.C., Q.C. From the Library of Parliament website.

  • Sir George-Étienne Cartier National Historic Site of CanadaBrief profile of Sir George-Étienne Cartier from Parks Canada.

  • Cartier, George-Etienne, Sir, 1814-1873Brief biography of Sir George-Étienne Cartier with digitized copies of related correspondence. From Manitobia.ca.

  • George-Etienne CartierA review of two biographies of Sir George-Étienne Cartier that examines his controversial political legacy. From the Manitoba Historical Society website.

  • Sir George-Étienne CartierA profile of Sir George-Étienne Cartier that focuses on his enthusiastic support for the fledgling railway industry in Canada. From the Canadian Railway Hall of Fame.

  • The Fathers of ConfederationA painting of the distinguished Fathers of Confederation. Part of the House of Commons Heritage Collection. From the website for the Parliament of Canada.

Jacques Cartier, the French navigator, established his country’s claim to present-day Canada through his explorations of the Gulf of St. Lawrence and the St. Lawrence River.

Jacques Cartier was born in 1491 in the French seaport town of Saint-Malo and later studied navigation in Dieppe. His early activities remain somewhat murky, but some historians have advanced the idea that he accompanied fishermen to Newfoundland in the 1520s. Other believe that Cartier sailed with Giovanni da Verrazzano on at least one of his voyages of discovery.

In any event, Cartier made his first documented voyage to the New World in 1534 under the auspices of Francis I. Enticed by the fabulous wealth being discovered by the Spanish, France hoped to do the same elsewhere in the Americas. Cartier’s ships sailed around the northern tip of Newfoundland and along its western coast into the Gulf of St. Lawrence. Cartier landed on the Gaspé Peninsula and formally claimed the area for France. The explorers befriended native inhabitants and received reports from them about the existence of gold and jewels farther inland. On the return voyage to France, Cartier took two Indian boys and a supply of maize, probably the first of that crop to reach Europe.

Jacques Cartier’s first voyage helped to change the French conception of North America. It had been widely believed that the area’s only value lay in its fisheries. Cartier’s report, however, described fertile lands and the possibility of mineral wealth.

A second voyage began in 1535. After returning his young Indian guests to their homes, Jacques Cartier began to explore the St. Lawrence River. He pushed up river to a native village at the base of a large mountain, which he named Mont Real (later Montréal). With winter approaching, Cartier sailed down the river and established a camp at the eventual site of Québec. The party returned to France the following spring.

In 1541, a new venture was formed under the leadership of Jean-François de la Rocque, Sieur de Roberval. Cartier sailed in advance of the main party and returned to the St. Lawrence. After leaving a small contingent at Québec to establish a settlement, Jacques Cartier led a fruitless search for gold. An already uncomfortable winter at camp was further marred by Indian attacks.

Advertisement

In the spring, Jacques Cartier’s force began the return voyage to France. They encountered the long-delayed Roberval party near Newfoundland, but refused an order to return to the St. Lawrence.

Cartier, despite his contributions to a better understanding of North American geography, was regarded as a failure. No gold was discovered and no lasting settlements were created. The areas he explored would remain largely untouched by Europeans until the early years of the next century. Jacques Cartier died at his manor of Limoilou on the first of September, 1551.


See France in the Age of Exploration.
See also Indian Wars Time Table.

Off-site search results for "Jacques Cartier"...

Jacques Cartier
Jacques Cartier (1491-1557) Jacques Cartier (1491-1557) was an explorer of the St. Lawrence River to present day Montreal. Cartier's exploration was the base for France's claim to Canada. Their origional intent was to search for thJacques Cartier (1491-1557) Jacques Cartier (1491-1557) was an explorer of the St. Lawrence River to present day Montreal. Cartier's exploration was the base for France's claim to Canada. Their origional intent was to search for thJacques Cartier (1491-1557) was an explorer of the St. Lawrence River to present day Montreal. Cartier's exploration was the base for France's claim to Canada. Their origional intent was to search for the Northwest ...
http://www.plpsd.mb.ca/amhs/history/cartier.html

European Explorers: Jacques Cartier
... Was Cartier || Voyages || Resources in French Who Was Cartier? Jacques Cartier Jacques Cartier was born in St. Malo (France) in 1491. Not much is known of his life before 1534, when he departed on his first voyage. He was loJacques Cartier Jacques Cartier was born in St. Malo (France) in 1491. Not much is known of his life before 1534, when he departed on his first voyage. He was loJacques Cartier was born in St. Malo (France) in 1491. Not much is known of his life before 1534, when he departed on his first voyage. He was looking for a ...
http://www.cdli.ca/CITE/excartier.htm

Discoverers Web: Jacques Cartier
... Historicus) (in French) The Voyages of Jacques Cartier (Mariner's Museum) Jacques Cartier (Encyclopédie de Saint-Pierre et Miquelon, in French) Jacques Cartier *explorer (SchoolNet) Jean-François de LaRocque de Roberval (La RocJacques Cartier (Mariner's Museum) Jacques Cartier (Encyclopédie de Saint-Pierre et Miquelon, in French) Jacques Cartier *explorer (SchoolNet) Jean-François de LaRocque de Roberval (La RocJacques Cartier (Encyclopédie de Saint-Pierre et Miquelon, in French) Jacques Cartier *explorer (SchoolNet) Jean-François de LaRocque de Roberval (La RocJacques Cartier *explorer (SchoolNet) Jean-François de LaRocque de Roberval (La Rocque) Gilles ...
http://www.win.tue.nl/~engels/discovery/cartier.html

One thought on “Jacques Cartier Problems Or Obstacles To Critical Thinking

Leave a comment

L'indirizzo email non verrà pubblicato. I campi obbligatori sono contrassegnati *